Pizza Ratings

Rank Name Score Crust Sauce Shape Comments Last Visited Share
1Jioio's9.25ThinSmoothSquareTrue representation if pizza were a pie.December 31, 2023Share
2Pelegrino's9.00Hand-tossedChunkyTriangleGood topping coverage and overall a delicious pizza.September 29, 2023Share
3Lilja's Premiere Pizza9.00Hand-tossedSweetTriangleVery sweet and delicious sauceSeptember 4, 2025Share
4Rockaway Pizzeria8.75Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleTraditional NYC style with big slices and good sauce August 3, 2024Share
5Corolla Pizza & Deli8.75Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleBest in OBXJune 7, 2025Share
6Mineo's8.50Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleEntire top slides easily off base. Lots of cheese with toppings underneath.May 25, 2023Share
7Luciano's Italian Brick Oven8.50Hand-tossedSweetTriangleFresh ingredients are apparent and well balanced combination July 23, 2023Share
8Campi's Pizza8.50ThickSweetTrianglePurchased at the Jamestown fair, and it was so delicious September 9, 2023Share
9Olives & Peppers8.50Hand-tossedChunkyTriangleVery good pizza, filling and good seasoning and toppings. Hidden gem. July 10, 2024Share
10Conca D'Oro Pizzeria8.50Hand-tossedSweetTriangleLots of cheese and sauce. Delicious. March 14, 2024Share
11Iron Born8.25DetroitChunkySquareDetroit-style, really thick with the sauce on top. Very filling.July 3, 2023Share
12Adrian's Pizza8.25Hand-tossedSweetTriangleComplete package with lots of cheese, sauce, and enjoyable crust. October 20, 2023Share
13Bishop's Pizza8.25Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleThicker hand tossed with flavorful sauceFebruary 4, 2025Share
14Conforti's Pizzeria8.25Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleGreasy AFMarch 14, 2025Share
15Abruzzi Italian Cucina8.25Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleSauces and yummyMay 3, 2025Share
16Slice on Broadway8.00New YorkChunkyTriangleNot bad and now as thin as New York actual pizzaJuly 5, 2023Share
17Giuseppe’s8.00Hand-tossedSmoothTrianglePacked toppings with lots of cheese. Standard hand tossed pizza that’s good anytime. July 9, 2023Share
18Lelulo's Pizzeria8.00Hand-tossedSweetTriangleA very good sweet sauce (but not overly sweet) pizza with good toppings.March 8, 2025Share
19Gino Bros Pizza Express8.00Hand-tossedChunkyTriangleGood pie with good sauce. Could use more cheese across the board, but all the flavors were goodSeptember 9, 2023Share
20Pizzeria Uno8.00Deep dishChunkyTriangleOriginal Chicago deep dish. I enjoyed just about everything about it. October 24, 2023Share
21A Slice of New York8.00New YorkSweetTriangleLarge slices and authentic NY style. The hot sausage topping was sliced like pepperoni February 24, 2024Share
22Ginny's Neighborhood Pizza Joint8.00Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleSlightly overcooked on top. Tasty hot sausageJuly 11, 2025Share
23MOD Pizza7.75Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleVery good crust compared to blaze. Crispy and not production tasting September 6, 2023Share
24Shelly Pie Pizza7.75Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleVery similar to the famous Vinny pie nearby. No paper was put in box so pizza stuck to the bottom.February 28, 2025Share
25Paulie Gee's Wicker Park7.75New YorkSmoothTriangleNot floppy but not burnt, deliciousNovember 20, 2024Share
26Angelo’s7.50Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleSlightly sparse toppings, but overall a good pie. Pretty consistent. September 21, 2023Share
27Aiello's Pizza North7.50Hand-tossedSweetTriangleA very good pizza with in-house made ingredients. Cheese and toppings were delicious. July 31, 2023Share
28Papa Rocks Pizza Pub7.50Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleGood all around pizza with good toppingsSeptember 5, 2023Share
29P T's Pizza7.50Hand-tossedSwweetTriangleSmaller pies but thicker than normal dough with puffy crust. Very good and well-made pizzaJuly 21, 2024Share
30Lucci's Pizza & Pasta7.50New YorkSweetTriangleSparse toppings but lots of sauce and good tasteFebruary 14, 2024Share
31Jioio's Restaurant7.50ThinSweetSquareI prefer the Greensburg location but this can do in a pinch.March 3, 2024Share
32Fellinis Pizzeria7.50Hand-tossedSweetTriangleJust great all aroundNovember 17, 2024Share
33Pie in the Sky7.50Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleGreasyDecember 22, 2024Share
34Mama Meatball's Pizzeria7.50Hand-tossedChunkyTriangleHerbyJanuary 19, 2025Share
35Napoli Pizza7.50Hand-tossedChunkyTriangleItaly style. Very good. February 20, 2025Share
36Donna Lynn’s7.25Hand-tossedChunkyTriangleLots of cheese and satisfying July 1, 2023Share
37Vocelli Pizza7.25Hand-tossedChunkyTriangleBetter than I remember March 28, 2025Share
38Doughboy's Pizza7.25Hand-tossedChunkyTriangleThick doughy crust, mostly mehApril 19, 2025Share
39Costco7.00ShellSweetTriangle Obvious frozen taste but is a top tier food court slice. July 17, 2023Share
40Bellisario's Restaurant7.00Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleGood greasy hand tossed pizza. Sauce could use some sprucing upAugust 22, 2023Share
41Pietro's Pizzeria7.00Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleNice crunch to each bite but sort of had a frozen shell vibe or pre prepared crust. Good basic pizza October 14, 2023Share
42Large Plain Pizza and Pints7.00SicilianSweetSquareGood dense and crispy crust. Not too thick or bready. Really similar to regular-style pizzaNovember 17, 2023Share
43Inferno Pizza7.00Hand-tossedChunkyTriangleLots of sauce and good tasting toppings. A little messy to eat when hot, but overall very tastyDecember 23, 2023Share
44Frothy Beard Brewing Company7.00Hand-tossedChunkyTriangleGood pub style pie with lots of cheese and crispy crust December 27, 2023Share
45Dom's Pizzeria7.00Hand-tossedChunkyTriangleOverall good basic doughy pizza. Nothing specialSeptember 29, 2024Share
46Gateway Grill7.00Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleGreasy and crustyOctober 31, 2024Share
47Pizano's Pizza & Pasta7.00Hand-tossedChunkySquareCrispy and tasty November 18, 2024Share
48Padrone's Pizza & Pub7.00Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleGood with extra cheeseDecember 13, 2024Share
49Colangelo’s6.75SicilianSweetSquareGood for being pre made and reheated July 21, 2023Share
50Bellisario's Sicilian Style6.75SicilianSweetSquareThick and bready pizza wish they would use this sauce on their hand-tossed pizza.August 22, 2023Share
51Warrior Pizza6.75Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleGood overall standard fresh made pizzaSeptember 7, 2024Share
52Frank's6.50Hand-tossedSweetTriangleTastes a little bland and related to arcade-style pizza. Not graded: excellent homemade ranch.July 13, 2023Share
53La Felice Pizza and Pasta6.50Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleGood crumbled sausage and overall enjoyable pizzaAugust 13, 2023Share
54Rising Crust Pizzeria6.50Hand-tossedChunkyTriangleNot bad overall, but something was off about it.October 7, 2023Share
55Napoli Pizza6.50Deep dishChunkyTriangleThick crust but no flavorMarch 1, 2025Share
56Caliente6.25Hand-tossedChunkyTriangleUnlike their claim, not the world's best pizza. The crust is the best thing about it.June 17, 2023Share
57Sir Pizza6.00ThinChunkySquareNot bad and a little different than traditional pizza. One level up from national chains. June 19, 2023Share
58Sam’s Club6.00ShellSmoothTriangleSub-par food court pizza July 21, 2023Share
59Pizza Hut - The Big New Yorker6.00ShellSweetTriangleThe best pizza from any of the national chains.August 6, 2023Share
60Fornello Pizzeria6.00Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleStandard hand-tossed pie with skimpy amounts of cheese and toppings.October 31, 2023Share
61Domino's Pizza6.00Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleGood, fast, and cheap pizza. Made fresh and tastes better than other chain pizza places.February 21, 2024Share
62Pizza Palermo6.00Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleStandard hand tossed pizza, nothing special June 29, 2024Share
63Real Good Pizza6.00Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleWell made pizza, but needs more sauceSeptember 22, 2024Share
64Home Run Inn6.00ShellChunkyTriangleNot terrible for airport pizza November 22, 2024Share
65Amili's Pizzeria Plum6.00Hand-tossedSmoothTriangleBasic hand tossed pizzaJanuary 15, 2025Share
66Grandslam Pizza5.50ShellSmoothTriangleMediocre apart from the sauceAugust 30, 2024Share
67Spak Brothers5.00Hand-tossedChunkyTriangleTastes like grocery store pizza. Not bad not good. August 12, 2023Share
68Fire & Ice Smokehouse & Creamery5.00ShellChunkyTriangleBasic concession pizzaFebruary 1, 2025Share
69Charlie's Choice Pizza4.50ShellSmoothTriangleBasic pizza, probably worse than a national chain.April 27, 2024Share

Our Approach to Pizza Rating

When it comes to rating pizza, I focus on three key components: the crust, the sauce, and the toppings.
While cheese is an essential part of pizza,
it usually doesn't have a significant impact on the rating.

To determine the overall score, I calculate the average of the individual scores for the crust, sauce, and toppings.
Now, the question arises: does the perfect pizza truly exist?



Last updated: 09/17/25

Send feedback on social media